Finding affordable car insurance can be tough—especially if you’re classified as a high-risk driver. Whether it’s due to a DUI, multiple traffic violations, poor credit, or being a new driver, insurers often charge much more when you’re seen as risky. Fortunately, not all companies treat high-risk drivers the same.
If you’re looking for the best car insurance for high-risk drivers USA, this guide is your go-to resource. We’ll explain what makes someone “high-risk,” which insurance companies offer the most competitive policies, and how to reduce your rates even if you’re in a higher-risk category.
Who Is Considered a High-Risk Driver?
Insurance companies label a driver as “high-risk” based on data that suggests they are more likely to file a claim. Here are common factors that may put you in this category:
-
DUI or DWI conviction
-
Multiple speeding tickets or moving violations
-
At-fault accidents
-
Lapse in insurance coverage
-
Poor credit history
-
Young or new drivers
-
Driving without a license or with a suspended license
Being high-risk doesn’t mean you’re uninsurable—but it usually means higher premiums and fewer insurer options.
Best Car Insurance Companies for High-Risk Drivers in the USA
Here’s a breakdown of top-rated car insurance companies that cater to high-risk drivers in the United States, based on affordability, customer service, and coverage options.
1. The General
Best for: Drivers with a poor driving history or credit issues
Why it stands out: The General specializes in non-standard auto insurance, offering coverage to drivers with DUIs, accidents, and poor credit scores.
Pros:
-
Fast quotes and policy issuance
-
Accepts most high-risk profiles
-
Nationwide availability
Cons:
-
Higher-than-average premiums
-
Basic customer service experience
2. Progressive
Best for: Drivers looking for discounts and usage-based programs
Why it stands out: Progressive’s Snapshot® program uses driving behavior to lower premiums, ideal for high-risk drivers who now drive safely.
Pros:
-
Discounts for safe driving habits
-
Offers SR-22 filing
-
Large network of agents and mobile app
Cons:
-
Rates vary widely by state
-
Snapshot could raise rates if you drive poorly
3. GEICO
Best for: Military members, government employees, and younger high-risk drivers
Why it stands out: GEICO is known for competitive pricing and flexible coverage, even for drivers with a blemished record.
Pros:
-
Low average rates for high-risk profiles
-
Fast claims handling
-
Many discount opportunities
Cons:
-
Limited local agents
-
Not the best choice for those requiring personalized service
4. State Farm
Best for: High-risk drivers looking to improve their record
Why it stands out: State Farm offers the Drive Safe & Save™ program, helping high-risk drivers gradually reduce their premiums through good driving behavior.
Pros:
-
SR-22 support
-
Strong reputation for claims service
-
Great bundling discounts
Cons:
-
Higher initial rates for high-risk drivers
-
Not available in all states
5. Dairyland
Best for: Drivers needing SR-22 and non-standard coverage
Why it stands out: Dairyland specializes in high-risk auto insurance and offers flexible payment options and coverage for drivers with suspended licenses or DUIs.
Pros:
-
SR-22 filing available
-
Accepts international and out-of-state licenses
-
Affordable monthly payment plans
Cons:
-
Limited availability in some regions
-
Mixed customer reviews
Key Coverage Types High-Risk Drivers Should Consider
Even as a high-risk driver, you can benefit from customized coverage:
-
Liability Insurance (required in most states)
-
Collision Coverage (for damage to your own car)
-
Comprehensive Coverage (for non-collision incidents)
-
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage
-
SR-22 Filing (if mandated by the court or DMV)
How Much Does Car Insurance Cost for High-Risk Drivers?
High-risk drivers typically pay 40% to 300% more than standard drivers. Here’s a sample cost comparison:
| Driving Profile | Average Monthly Premium |
|---|---|
| Clean driving record | $130–$170 |
| 1 at-fault accident | $180–$250 |
| DUI conviction | $250–$400+ |
| Multiple speeding violations | $200–$300 |
| Lapsed insurance coverage | $180–$250 |
Note: Rates vary by state, insurer, vehicle type, and credit history.
Tips to Lower Car Insurance as a High-Risk Driver
1. Take a Defensive Driving Course
Completing a certified defensive driving course can help reduce your premiums and improve your record.
2. Opt for Usage-Based Insurance
Programs like Progressive’s Snapshot or State Farm’s Drive Safe & Save monitor your driving habits to offer discounts for safe driving.
3. Improve Your Credit Score
In many states, your credit score affects your premium. Pay bills on time and reduce debt to improve rates over time.
4. Bundle Insurance Policies
Combine auto with renters, homeowners, or life insurance to receive multi-policy discounts.
5. Compare Multiple Quotes
Use online comparison tools or independent agents to find the best deal tailored to your high-risk profile.
FAQs About Best Car Insurance for High-Risk Drivers USA
Q1. What is the cheapest car insurance for high-risk drivers?
The General and Dairyland often offer the lowest premiums for high-risk drivers, especially those needing SR-22 coverage.
Q2. Can high-risk drivers get full coverage?
Yes. While more expensive, high-risk drivers can still qualify for full coverage, including liability, collision, and comprehensive protection.
Q3. What is an SR-22, and do I need one?
An SR-22 is a certificate proving you carry the minimum required car insurance. It’s often required after a DUI or driving without insurance.
Q4. How long does someone stay classified as high-risk?
Usually, violations remain on your driving record for 3 to 5 years, after which you may be reclassified if you maintain a clean record.
Q5. Can I switch insurance providers as a high-risk driver?
Yes. In fact, shopping around regularly is one of the best ways for high-risk drivers to find better rates and service.
Summary
Being labeled a high-risk driver in the USA doesn’t mean you’re out of options. Insurers like The General, Progressive, GEICO, State Farm, and Dairyland offer tailored coverage—even if your record includes violations, DUIs, or accidents.
While premiums will be higher, smart strategies like comparing quotes, improving your credit, and enrolling in safe driving programs can help you cut costs over time.
Conclusion
The road to affordable car insurance might be bumpy if you’re a high-risk driver, but it’s not a dead end. By choosing the best car insurance providers for high-risk drivers in the USA, you can secure the coverage you need—without paying more than necessary.
Every insurer has different criteria, rates, and tolerance for risk. That’s why it’s essential to shop around, ask the right questions, and make informed choices. Whether you’re recovering from a DUI or just getting started as a new driver, the right policy can protect your finances—and your peace of mind—while you work toward a cleaner driving record.
About the Author
